Chris Kavanagh refereed a 17:30 UK kick-off at St James' Park in front of 52,661. Matthias Jaissle's Newcastle and Mikel Arteta's Arsenal both lined up four-two-three-one. Newcastle had Horníček in goal; Hall, Burn, Thiaw and Dedić across the back; Miley and Steur in midfield; and Barnes, Willock and Murphy behind Osula. Arsenal had David Raya in goal; Calafiori, Gabriel Magalhães, Konsa and Timber in defence; Rice and Bruno Guimarães in front of them; and Eze, Ødegaard and Madueke behind Havertz.
Dedić was booked in the 23rd minute, and in the 33rd Eze put Arsenal ahead, assisted by Havertz. The half-time score was Newcastle United 0-1 Arsenal.
Jaissle sent on Elanga for Murphy, Livramento for Dedić and Ramsey for Steur at the break. Barnes equalised in the 49th minute, Rice was booked in the 56th and Barnes in the 58th, and Thiaw's goal in the 62nd put Newcastle in front. Arteta replaced David Raya with Kepa, Bruno Guimarães with Lewis-Skelly and Eze with Tzolis in the 70th minute, and Madueke drew Arsenal level in the 78th. Burn and Madueke were booked in the 81st, Wissa replaced Willock in the 83rd and Botman came on for Hall in the 92nd. Gyökeres and Mikel Merino replaced Havertz and Ødegaard in the 94th, and Gyökeres was booked at 90+10.
Newcastle had 34 per cent of the ball and completed 188 of their 256 passes, 73.4 per cent, against Arsenal's 446 of 519 at 85.9 per cent. Shots went 12 to 13, three on target to four, and touches in the opposition box 15 to 24. On those numbers, with 12 shots to 13 from 34 per cent of the ball to 66, Newcastle shot nearly as often as Arsenal with much less of the ball.
Newcastle committed 19 fouls to Arsenal's seven and made 15 tackles, winning 10, to Arsenal's seven and four. Newcastle won 20 aerial duels to Arsenal's 15 and 45 duels in all to Arsenal's 46. On those figures, 19 fouls to seven and 15 tackles to seven, Newcastle did far more of the challenging.
Before this game Newcastle's form guide held a Premier League draw with Fulham, Premier League defeats by Everton and Aston Villa, a League Cup defeat by Everton and a Premier League win over Crystal Palace. Arsenal's held Premier League wins over Hull City, Liverpool and Everton, a Champions League win over Slavia Prague and a League Cup draw with Fleetwood Town.